I suffered occasional pain/bleeding with BMs for years. Usually, it didn't last very long and would clear up within a few days by itself, maybe with some Vitamin A&D ointment application.
A few months ago, I had an outbreak that was similar to what I was used to, but after a day or two, it got worse, not better. I waited a few more days, before contacting my doctor via email. At that point, I was experiencing the intense pain associated with an anal fissure. The description of passing broken glass through my butt was frighteningly accurate. My doctor prescribed me some steroid suppositories, and things got better within a week or so.
Unfortunately, the pain returned within perhaps a month or so. Again. in the past, this had happened before. But the pain was less intense and the time between episodes was quite a bit longer. This time I made an appointment to see my doctor. By the time I was able to get in to see her, the fissure had subsided a little bit. But she confirmed that it was probably a fissure, prescribed some more suppositories, and had me make an appointment with GI specialist for a sigmoidoscopy.
It was another week or so before I could see the GI guy. That was a nightmare! A sigmoidoscopy doesn't really have anything to do with AF. My doctor just had me go to check for polyps. The GI doctor examined my sphincter before inserting the camera for the sigmoidoscopy. He was incredibly insensitive! I told him why I was having the procedure. He said that my butt looked a bit irritated, and proceeded to aggravate the AF during his exam despite my obvious discomfort. I didn't yell, but he asked where/how it hurt and I told him it was extremely unpleasant while he continued to stimulate the area. After the sigmoidoscopy didn't reveal anything, I asked him what this meant about my AF and he didn't address my concerns at all. WTF was the point of the procedure then!
That was about a week ago. The irritation/pain I have been experiencing has been chronic. While the pain associated with BM has lessened to a degree, the pain in my anal area is worse and does not go away. It is both burning and throbbing at times.
My sphincter feels like it's been rubbed raw with sandpaper. Extended sitting is awful, standing can be irritating too. Lying down is the best. I've tried various OTC ointments to little avail. Aspercreme has been somewhat effective in mitigating the pain, but the relief is mild (at best) and temporary.
It's nice to know that I'm not the only one suffering. I look forward to trying some of the various treatment plans others have. But the idea that this could be a permanent thing is depressing.