just before xmas 2008 was when I developed my a/f "problem". The first 8 months was the worst time in my life, what a puzzling and horrible condition. The spasms and burning hot coal pain was relentless. Creams, potions, doctors - nothing. Trust me I did everything you have all done.
The only thing I have not tried is surgery - so here we are as I celebrate 5 long years - over time, my symptoms SLOWLY improved, in fact I had moments where I thought i was healed. But, it always comes back, always, well for me anyways.
The one thing that has helped me more than anything I have tried: MAGNESIUM CITRATE, 600 mg a day. If you want soft evacuation, this is it. I recommend everyone try it. It has not cured me but has helped me greatly.