Hi Drew37619, and

to the forum.
We are not able to diagnose your problem; that is the role of your doctor and would suggest that you make an appointment to see either a GP,or a Colon and Rectal Surgeon (CRS).
Hydrocortisone is usually given for hemorrhoids, not for anal fissures.
Please read through the many posts on here on diet, drinking water, fiber, laxatives and more.
Just a guess, and nothing more than that, is that you are going through a healing anal fissure, as you said that you previously experienced pain when having a BM, but now you are only experiencing itching. Hemorrhoids, in my experience, do not cause much itching unless they are inflamed. I have had three surgeries for hemorrhoids and itching was not one of the sensations. Excruiating pain, yes...
You are only 18, the fissure - if you have one - has more of a chance to heal if you catch it early (you don't say how long you had/have had it). So make an appointment to see your doctor - about the itching too which could be a number of things - and keep in touch with us to say how you are doing.
All the best!